Experiential Learning: A Comprehensive Guide for Mentors

Think of experiential learning at work like learning to ride a bike, but for job skills. Instead of just talking about how to do something, you actually get your hands dirty and try it out. 

Research shows why this matters: Students involved in experiential learning were more engaged, scored better grades and had higher retention rates compared to those who weren't. When people learn by doing, they're not only more likely to stick around but also to excel in what they're doing. 

In the workplace, employees might work on a special project, try different jobs at your company, or team up with someone more experienced to accelerate their professional development. 

What is experiential learning

Experiential learning is a process through which individuals develop knowledge, skills, and values from direct experiences. It emphasizes engagement in processes of learning through experience and reflection, leading to personal and professional growth.

Experiential learning allows individuals to:

• Engage in real-world tasks: Employees undertake real, meaningful projects or tasks that contribute to the organization's goals. This could involve participating in a new product launch, leading a team through a challenging project, or managing a cross-departmental initiative.
• Reflect on their experiences: After engaging in these tasks, employees take time to reflect on their experiences. This reflection could be facilitated by mentors or through self-reflection exercises. The goal is to derive lessons from what was done, what outcomes were achieved, and how processes can be improved.
• Develop and test new ideas: Based on their reflections, employees are encouraged to conceptualize new approaches, strategies, or solutions to improve work outcomes. This might involve developing a new process to increase efficiency or designing a training program for new hires.
• Apply what they've learned: Finally, employees apply their new understanding or approaches in the workplace, testing the effectiveness of their ideas and making adjustments based on outcomes. This cycle of application and reflection continues, fostering ongoing learning and improvement.

Examples of experiential learning in the workplace

Experiential learning is a key driver of professional development. Here’s what it looks like in practice:

Project-based learning: An employee is tasked with leading a project outside of their usual responsibilities, providing an opportunity to develop leadership and project management skills.

Job rotation programs: Employees spend time working in different departments or roles within the organization, gaining a broader understanding of the business operations and developing new skills.

Simulations and role-playing: Teams engage in simulated business challenges or role-playing exercises to develop skills in areas like negotiation, conflict resolution, or strategic planning.

Peer coaching and mentoring: More experienced employees mentor newer ones, providing a practical learning experience that benefits both parties.

Innovation labs: Employees participate in brainstorming sessions or workshops aimed at developing new ideas for products, services, or processes, fostering creativity and innovation.

‍

Kolb's Experiential Learning Theory

David Kolb's Experiential Learning Theory outlines a four-stage cycle of learning, comprising concrete experience, reflective observation, abstract conceptualization, and active experimentation. This cycle suggests that effective learning involves going through these stages, allowing learners to experience, reflect, conceptualize, and apply their knowledge.

4 stages of Kolb's Experiential Learning Theory

Concrete Experience

Employees learn best when they are directly involved in a task. For example, a new project assignment that pushes them out of their comfort zones can serve as a powerful concrete experience.

Reflective Observation

Encouraging employees to reflect on their experiences is crucial. Techniques like guided debriefs or reflective journaling can help. According to the Queen's University report, structured reflection increases the depth of learning by over 20%.

Abstract Conceptualization

Learners then conceptualize their observations, forming theories or models. Workshops or brainstorming sessions can facilitate this, helping employees develop innovative solutions to problems encountered during their experiences.

Active Experimentation

Finally, employees apply their new insights in real-world settings. This could involve piloting a new process based on lessons learned from a project, fostering a culture of continuous learning and innovation.

Benefits of Experiential Learning

Studies point to the substantial benefits of experiential learning, including improved engagement and performance among learners. A Queen’s University report cites that students engaged in experiential learning show a significant increase in retention rates and academic performance, suggesting similar outcomes can be expected in workplace settings. 

Role of mentors in experiential learning

Mentors play a crucial role in the experiential learning process by offering guidance, support, and insight that enrich the learning experience for the mentee. Here’s how mentors play a key role:

Creating a supportive environment

• Encouraging risk-taking: Mentorship can help mentees feel safe to take risks and step out of their comfort zones. For example, mentors might encourage an employee to lead a project team for the first time, providing a safety net through regular check-ins and support.
• Normalizing failure as part of learning: Illustrate the learning potential from failure through sharing personal stories or case studies where failure led to significant insights and improvements. This approach helps to destigmatize failure and promote a growth mindset.

Facilitating the learning process

• Guiding through reflection: After a mentee completes an experiential learning activity, mentors can facilitate a reflection session to help them articulate what they learned, how they felt, and what they might do differently in the future. This could be structured through guided questions or a reflection template.
• Encouraging application of new insights: Mentors can help mentees apply their new knowledge or skills to different contexts, enhancing their versatility and adaptability. For instance, if an employee learns a new software tool during a project, the mentor can suggest other projects or tasks where this tool could be beneficial.

Developing critical thinking and problem-solving skills

• Challenging assumptions: Mentors can present scenarios or questions that challenge mentees to rethink assumptions or consider alternative perspectives. This might involve discussing theoretical scenarios related to their work or examining case studies from different industries.
• Promoting solution-oriented thinking: Encourage mentees to identify problems in their work area and brainstorm potential solutions. For example, if a mentee identifies a recurring bottleneck in a process, the mentor can guide them through developing a project to investigate and address the issue.

Building confidence and leadership skills

• Providing opportunities for leadership: Mentors can arrange for mentees to take on leadership roles in small projects or teams, gradually increasing their responsibility as their confidence grows. Feedback and reflection after these leadership experiences are crucial for development.
• Recognizing and celebrating achievements: Celebrate successes and milestones, no matter how small, to build confidence. For example, if a mentee successfully implements a new process they developed, the mentor can recognize this achievement in team meetings or company newsletters.

Facilitating networking and relationship building

• Introducing to professional networks: Mentors can help mentees expand their professional networks by introducing them to colleagues, industry contacts, or professional groups. This might include inviting mentees to networking events or facilitating introductions to key stakeholders within the organization.
• Encouraging collaboration: Set up opportunities for mentees to collaborate with others outside their usual workgroup. This could be cross-departmental projects or mentorship circles, providing diverse perspectives and fostering a sense of community.

Joan Skelton, Global Director, Diversity & Inclusion at Avison Young, talks about the impact of mentorship at her organization.

‍

How to design experiential learning opportunities

Keep the strategic needs of the organization in mind and provide meaningful, real-world learning experiences for employees. Here’s how to design effective experiential learning opportunities.

Align with organizational goals

To ensure experiential learning initiatives are successful and relevant, they must directly support the organization's strategic objectives. 

For example, if a company is focused on improving its customer service ratings, an experiential learning project might involve a team of employees analyzing current customer feedback, identifying key areas for improvement, and then designing and testing new feedback mechanisms. This could include creating a more user-friendly online survey or developing a system for real-time feedback via a customer service app.

Use techniques for effective reflection

Reflection is a critical component of experiential learning, allowing employees to internalize what they've learned from their experiences. Incorporate structured reflection sessions using guided questions or scenarios that prompt employees to think deeply about their experiences, the outcomes, and how they can apply their learning in future situations. 

For instance, after completing a project, a team might hold a debrief session where they discuss what worked well, what challenges they encountered, and how they can improve similar projects in the future. These discussions can be guided by questions such as, "What was the most unexpected outcome of this project, and why do you think it happened?" or "How can we apply the lessons learned from this project to our next initiative?"

Create a continuous feedback loop

For experiential learning to be truly effective, it needs to be accompanied by timely, constructive feedback. Establish regular check-ins or review meetings where mentors, managers, and their mentees can discuss progress, address challenges, and celebrate achievements. 

This ongoing dialogue ensures that employees are not only recognized for their efforts but also aware of areas where they can improve. For example, after presenting a new marketing strategy developed through an experiential learning project, the team could receive feedback not just on the content of their presentation but also on their collaboration, problem-solving, and project management skills.

Navigate common hurdles

While experiential learning offers numerous benefits, its implementation can be met with challenges, such as budget constraints, time limitations, or skepticism from employees used to more traditional learning methods. To address these hurdles, securing executive buy-in is crucial. 

Demonstrating the value of experiential learning through small-scale pilot programs can help make the case. For instance, a pilot program could involve a small team working on an innovative project to solve a long-standing issue. The success of this project can then be showcased as a proof of concept for the efficacy of experiential learning. Gradually, as these initiatives show positive results, experiential learning practices can become more integrated into the organization's culture, with broader buy-in from across the company.

Start small by identifying a specific area 

In conclusion, find an area within your organization where experiential learning can immediately add value—whether it's improving customer service, enhancing product development, or increasing operational efficiency. Develop a pilot experiential learning project in this area, incorporating structured reflection and feedback mechanisms.

Use the outcomes of this pilot to refine your approach and gradually expand experiential learning initiatives across the organization, always ensuring alignment with strategic goals and fostering an environment that values continuous learning and growth. This step-by-step approach will not only prove the effectiveness of experiential learning but also help to cultivate a culture that embraces innovation and adaptability.

Book a free demo to see how Together unlocks experiential learning by matching mentors and mentees.